Ezra’s posterous

because i'm too lazy to think of something witty. 
« Back to blog

I am pro-Palestinian

For around 8 months, I have been sharing many details of my life, my thoughts, my quirks and my aspirations. I feel quite guilty that I have been extremely silent over the past few weeks what has been going through my mind and what I have been working on, and the reasons behind what I am currently spending time on.

I am pro-Palestinian. I grew up with the dream of Yitzhak Rabin, of a two-state solution, that would allow both Israelis and Palestinians lead normal lives. Lives where children can dream beyond the current conflict. Lives where people can sit in a cafe and chat for hours about nothing and everything, without fear of a random act of terror. Lives where people live, have jobs, and raise children to love, not hate; to respect difference, not fear it.

I live in the paradox of the modern Israeli.

We have learned to want peace at almost any cost. We have uprooted Israeli families from their long established homes, destroying communities. Just in order to give more land and self government to the Palestinians in Gaza. So they can live normal lives.

In spite of that, Southern Israel has been living under a constant barrage of rockets from Hamas, a terrorist organization that has usurped the democratic process for an extremely non-democratic venture. They feel that we should not exist as a country, as a people, and will do whatever they can do strike fear into our citizen's hearts at every moment of the day.

These rockets cause damage, hurt and even kill. But more than all that, they prevent people from living normal lives. They cause people to live in fear. That maybe their child's nursery will be struck with a "stray" rocket. That if they are in a public intersection, a projectile may simply fall from heaven. That the house that they have created all their memories in will be destroyed in an instant.

And in here lies the paradox. Israel does not want war. We love life.

I was approached by a good friend to help on a grassroots project to help spread the word about the Israeli side of the current conflict using Social Media tools. In this capacity, I have been reading scores of articles over the last few weeks. I have, as well, been privy to the progress reports that the Israeli Army has published on a daily basis, including detailed information regarding the ongoing humanitarian efforts from the Israeli side for the Palestinians in Gaza. 

I am disgusted by Hamas. I am disgusted by their use of Palestinians as human shields, and their storing firepower in and firing rockets from mosques, schools, hospitals, and private homes.  Israel uses extremely precise missiles, and even warns citizens about impending actions, but is being painted as a murderous nation, with words flitting around the media such as "genocide" or "holocaust". Considering that Israel treats wounded Palestinians, I find that portrait appalling.

This is not a post to discuss the humanitarian efforts of the Israelis or the utter disregard for human life of Hamas, but rather to be honest. I have chosen not to fill my twitter stream with every single report when something happens, because I respect that people don't want to be confronted with this 100 times a day. I am simply trying to include you in my internal conversation. I battle with myself every day juggling my natural aversion to war and the constant threat on my countrymen.

I want this battle to end. But until it does, I will stand behind my country in whatever they do, because I know that this is not a battle for land or control, it is a battle for a better future for all of us. A battle for normalcy. Normal lives for both Palestinians and Israelis.



If you choose to comment on this post (and I hope that you will), I can only request that you please respect me as a person and refrain from ad hominem attacks. I am highly capable of intelligent and reasonable conversation, and reserve the right to delete any comment that is full of vitriol and hate.

Comments (32)

Jan 14, 2009
Hillel said...
Ezra,
I agree with your ideas in general, but I still do not like that one sentence, it is misleading. You are pro Palestinian maybe in a different reality where they are peace loving and not in the current state of affairs in which they elected and support Hamas.
Jan 14, 2009
Nadia Levene said...
Ezra - I totally agree with your thoughts and get what you're saying about being pro-Palestinian. They need to think what's best them and need to vote in a government who can put their best intentions first - in setting up infrastructure rather than buying arms to attack us. My heart goes out to all those innocents being killed in Gaza. It is just the worst! But I don't blame Israel for defending herself. I'm just really worried that after this conflict, the Gazans will just hate us even more (along with most of the arabs worldwide) - and then WHERE will we be along with our hopes for peace?
Nadia
Jan 14, 2009
Ouriel Ohayon said...
great post. i wish this sound of wisdom was louder than the sound of ignorance surrounding us
Jan 14, 2009
Shaiel said...
Hi Ezra. Too bad Palestinians aren't pro-Palestinian like you are. When they are, then maybe we can have peace with them. Meanwhile, maybe another ceasefire, but let us bring Gilad home and let the ceasefire be on our terms this time.

Shaiel

Jan 14, 2009
Or-Tal said...
Great post. I share your thoughts and feelings. We have no other choice at the moment, but I do want to urge people to think of the tomorrow. Of the things we can do to make us a better future.
I believe that huge investments in education should be the first step. And have a lot more to say about it...
Jan 14, 2009
Charlie Kalech said...
Hillel. This is the only reality. The Palestinians are people and we are all victims of war and terror and poor leadership. They had a choice between the corrupt mafia of Fatah which exploited the people and crushed their economy or Islamic fundamentalists who had set up schools and soup kitchens while spewing terror to the perceived enemy. Do you really think most Palestinians in Gaza want to live how they live and want Hamas' vision for their children?
Jan 14, 2009
Mark said...
Ezra,

Well written. I do, however, have a general problem when people brand themselves as "pro" something without necessarily taking into consideration that making such a statement is parallel to saying you are "anti" something else. In this case, even though I know it is not the case, someone branding themselves as "pro-Palestinian" would lead readers who do not know you to believe that you are "anti-Israeli". Could you clarify?

Mark

Jan 14, 2009
Joel Katz said...
Ezra,

When you catch your breath after this project is over - I'd be interested in your impressions on the use of social media in "fighting" a war.

Joel

Jan 14, 2009
Igor The Troll said...
Good post. Keep spreading the words about Israel on Social Media networks. Baruh Hashem. Amein
Jan 14, 2009
Richard Shaffer said...
Nice post. Hamas should maybe think about becoming Pro-Palestinian like you are (clearly they are most decidedly NOT Pro-Palestinian).
Jan 14, 2009
Einat said...
I will not get into whether I agree with you or not, just one little comment (which by no means tries to justify what Hamas has been doing in the last few years):
"Hamas, a terrorist organization that has usurped the democratic process for an extremely non-democratic venture".
This is simply not true. Hamas won what was perhaps the most democratic process to have been conducted in our region (apart from in Israel). The attempt of Israel and other countries to delegitimise Hamas after its victory is in my opinion part of the problem we face now. Hamas was chosen by the Palestinians exactly because they believed that this will make their lives better (especially because Hamas was considered far less corrupt than fatah). Whether this has proven to be the right choice or not, is first of all for the Palestinians to say.
Again- I am not saying that Israel should not defend itself against violence. It is actually even easier in many ways to defend ourselves against something we have indeed acknowledged...
Jan 14, 2009
Miriam Schwab said...
Very thoughtful post, and unlike others here, I think the title is very powerful.
Jan 14, 2009
Xavier said...
Nice post, Ezra.
For those of you whe speak French it echoes this great BHL's article http://www.lepoint.fr/actualites-chroniques/liberer-les-palestiniens-du-hamas/989/0/305272

Einat,
I agree with your statement "delegitimise Hamas after its victory is in my opinion part of the problem"
Since the election of Hitler in Germany, we know that a too-poor too-uneducated humiliated people can use democracy to bring to power evil leaders. That's what happened with the election of Hamas.
I believe the reaction of western countries to the election of Hamas has been as wrong as it had been with Hitler. The only way to bring down a "legitimate" evil government is to corner it into its own contradictions to open the eyes of its people. Not to isolate it and reinforce, for those who have elected it, the sentiment of martyrdom.
Today, the military infrastructure built by the Hamas to terrorize Israel population needs to be destroyed. There is no question about it.
After the dust settles, what can one do to take the Palestinians of Gaza out of the negative spiral loop of poverty-anger-war-poverty? What can its richer neighbors (Israel, Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria) do to rebuild an economic and political landscape in this devastated territory? When will exiled educated Palestinians come back to take control of the fate of this people and bring them to peace?

Jan 14, 2009
Chaviva said...
Interesting post, and definitely an interesting post TITLE. I guess, in my mind, you're pro-peace, making you pro-Israeli and pro-Palestinian, but just saying pro-Palestinian is likely to rile the feathers of your Jewish counterparts. For me, I think saying I'm pro-peace is enough.
Jan 14, 2009
Richard Shaffer said...
I think the underlying point (and oddly to me a lot of people don't today agree with these basic concepts) is that there are in the world Good Guys and Bad Guys. Any child who has ever played Cops & Robbers in the backyard knows this, but lots of "well-educated" adults no longer believe it. They should. Wake up to the real world. The Good Guys may not be "perfect" but they're Good. And Evil really exists; it's different from Santa Claus.
Jan 14, 2009
Ezra Butler said...
Einat:

My intentions for the usage of the word "usurped" is because the term democracy, at least to the understanding of the Western world, has more meaning than simply meaning  "each person has the right to vote". There are morals that are associated with modern democracy transcend that, including such insignificant ideas such as "freedom of speech", due process, and a bunch of other fun ideals.

I will agree with you that Hamas was better with community oriented endeavors, but the end game was simple to garner support of the masses. Additionally, when schools are built parents are happy. When the curriculum is hatred, we have a problem.

Hamas never stopped the rocket attacks, even after they were elected.

Mark:

I am Pro-Palestinian and Anti-Hamas. I hope that that is clear enough.

 

Jan 14, 2009
Ezra Butler said...
Chaviva:

The reason that I chose the title Pro-Palestinian was simple. I can agree with many of the goals of the Pro-Palestinian movement.
It is shocking to see polls break the sides down into Israel and Palestine. In my estimation, the sides are Israel and Hamas.

Jan 14, 2009
Charlie Kalech said...
Ezra -
The power of American style Democracy is the Bill Rights. That is not just 50% + 1 but also the protection of minorities and civil rights. Unfortunately Israel also has a long way in fulfilling this goal among all minorities Jews and non-Jews.
Jan 14, 2009
Shmuel said...
Ezra,

Interesting post. I too take umbrage with the title. Unfortunately, because of biased media, and pure and unadulterated anti-Jewish and anti-Israel sentiments, almost everyone associates being Palestinian with being a second-class, poor, downtrodden, oppressed people. The truth is, as has been mentioned many times, that there really is no such national identity as a Palestinian. If you want to argue that Israel was called Palestine before it was called Israel (but only after it was called the land of Israel?), then you also need to include ALL people who lived here during that time, including the Jews, and Christians. Clearly, most of these people don't live in Aza today.

Yes, it's horrible to see how a people can be oppressed, murdered, and brain-washed, not by a neighboring nation (who should be proud of what it has accomplished in the last 60 years of its existence) who actually wants to just be left alone to live in peace, but by its own people! You said that you are privy to special information and have done a lot of reading about the current situation. I'm sure you've come across documentation about how Hamas has taken over Aza and has literally eliminated the competition, and has terrorized their own people. However, don't forget that the people living in Aza elected them fair and square. This is what they wanted. They wanted rockets being shot into Israel. They wanted soldiers and civilians to be kidnapped, tortured, and killed. They want to continue the institution of suicide bombing, stabbing attacks, rock throwing, etc., etc., etc. This is not a people that I'm pro-anything for except death. The Muslims living in Aza, and unfortunately much of the world these days, is nothing more than a death cult!

I consider myself pro-life (nothing to do with abortion). But I consider myself pro-life with a sanity check. If someone has every intention to try to kill me, you better believe I'm going to try to kill him before he gets me! As you mentioned, Israelis love life, and I love life too. I want to lead a peaceful life. One without having to fear where the next attack is going to come from. Is it going to be Aza? Is it going to be Lebanon? Is it going to be Egypt? Is it going to be Syria? Enough is enough.

I consider myself pro-peace. But I consider myself pro-peace for peace' sake, not for a piece of this and a piece of that. I think it was Golda Meir who said that the Arabs will stop attacking us when they love their children more than they hate us. So far there isn't too much from the Arab world that looks encouraging. Also, what about all those poor refugees who are still in camps in all the Arab countries? Why haven't they absorbed them? They haven't absorbed them because they don't want them either! To sum up how the Arab world feels about these people: Jordan killed tens of thousands of them on Black Sunday! Where was the outcry then? Also, we tried the piece of this and piece of that approach. I live across the street from hundreds of families who were evicted from their homes, their lives and livelihoods destroyed with the sole intention of giving their land to these Arabs. And it didn't even help one iota! We're all now within Katyusha range! Enticements don't and won't work.

I too want the war to end soon and bring our boys home safe and sound. I also want it to end with the complete and total annihilation of Aza and the return of our people to their communities there. Then and only then will we have a reprieve of missiles raining down on us from that direction! It'll also restore faith in HKB"H and His might for meeting out justice, and in the strength of the Israeli military, as well as scare the rest of the Arab world into not wanting to mess with us...for the time being. As for the rest of the world? They hate us no matter what, so what does it matter?!?! It seems harsh, but why is every other country allowed to fight a war as a war except Israel? This is WAR people! Don't like it? Don't get in the way!

Jan 14, 2009
Jordan Salvit said...
Very nicely put. It is nice to know that you are using your social media skills to help educate people of Israel's side. Are you planning on using these skills to help move on after the war?
Everyone has been commenting on the title, but I would like to reinforce Or-Tal's comment. What about tomorrow?
Jan 14, 2009
Charlie Kalech said...
I find Shmuel's comments very depressing. By denying the reality of today for the messages of yesteryear he has become blind to the visions of a better future.

While there may never have been a Palestinian people or national identity, today there is. That is reality.

Fatah, Jordan, Egypt, Saudi Arabia have all condemned Hamas - this is revolutionary and the results of decades of talk.

To proceed from a mentality that confirms thoughts like "As for the rest of the world? They hate us no matter what, so what does it matter?!?!" is to take leaps backwards to the shtetl mentality of the persecuted and helpless Jew and not to acknowledge the tremendous accomplishments we have made both on the world stage and in the region.

Jan 15, 2009
Nadia Levene said...
I totally agree with Charlie and disagree with Shmuel. NO! It is totally WRONG to end the war "with the complete and total annihilation of Gaza and the return of our people to their communities there"! We left for them to create an independent state there - they should care about their citizens; they should use the funding they're getting from around the world to build infrastructure, for education and NOT for ammunition against us.....but I too feel saddened for our future. I agree that the only hope is the fact that many many other Arab countries have condemned Hamas....let's hope and pray that this fact will push a peace process forward.
Jan 15, 2009
Sandy Kalik said...
Ezra-

Just wanted to say thank you for everything your doing--changing perceptions starts with an individual's ability to stand up and speak their mind, to as many people as possible. ;-)

I stand with you and I stand with Israel, as I always have. And I'm certainly not the only one here supporting her--I went to a rally for Israel in a local suburb last week and some of the biggest names in the state were there to show their support. President of the Mass ALF-CIO Bobby Haynes and Massachusetts Governor Deval Patrick both spoke on behalf of Israel in this war.

No one in their right mind wants war. It's a task undertaken with absolute reluctance, but always in the hope that it doesn't have to come to blows again.

I hear you.

Jan 16, 2009
Hmm... Despite the noble objectives that Israel has(according to you), the means used to achieve them are as shameful as those used by Hamas. Chemical warfare? Mass murder? It's the same on both sides.
Jan 16, 2009
Ezra Butler said...
@Rameez,

I would have to unfortunately disagree with you on what Israel is doing.

To begin with: Every life is precious. To that end, Israel calls places where they are going to hit, as well as informs them with fliers.
Is that the work of "mass murderers"? Israel left Gaza. Israel doesn't want to be in Gaza anymore.

Hamas chooses to use human shields, and keep women and children in houses that they know contain firepower and rocket launching spots.

I am going to refuse to play a numbers game, because everyone disagrees on what those numbers are (i.e. what percentage are hamas and what percentage are civilian), but I would contend that even those numbers are not saying the true story.

Take, for example, Israel. While their internal management tactics are far from perfect, they have air-raid sirens in every city, as well as bomb shelters, which have been used to protect from everything like Qassam rockets to Scud Missiles. Untold lives have been saved because they were able to hurry to a safe room.

The accusation of chemical warfare is interesting, but 1) even the ICRC says that Israel was not using white phosphorous is an illegal manner, and 2) white phosphorous is not considered a chemical weapon. (source).

War is dangerous, on both sides, just like you wrote. I want it to stop. But in order to respond to rocket attacks against Israel from populated places, after warning the people to disperse, what else can Israel do?

Thank you,

Ezra


Jan 16, 2009
if your neighbors voted in an elected government to attack another group of neighbors, I would consider it my Democratic duty to counter that by destroying the rockets from within. I hear little of movement against Hamas within Gaza and little against Hezbollah in Lebanon. I understand that you are trying to be "diplomatic", but with who? Who is it that you feel is your friend? Who is it that you feel is a peace partner? The guy who let's the guy next door keep a rocket aimed at your house is not friendly. If there was momentum in their community we would not be here. I am not going to pretend I have friends where I don't anymore. DOWN WITH TWITTER and the MEDIA ELITE!
Jan 17, 2009
terminal said...
I agree with your thoughts but they are only personal. That is okay, interesting and so on but in order to understand the whole conflict i think one has to view also the economic and politic dimensions. If there were progressive resistance in gaza (fighting for human rights and peace instead of religious beliefs) i would support it. But there isn't and because of that it is in my opinion a war between civilization and people who want to destroy the 'freedom' of the modern world. (Ever thought of gays in hamas supporting iran? What happens to them?)
Jan 17, 2009
Charlie Kalech said...
terminal:
I agree with your sentiment but it comes from a very Western point of view, one which assumes that the freedom exists to fight for human rights and peace and even alternative political and religious beliefs.

People in Gaza are scared and have no vision of a future for their children. They voted for Hamas as an alternative to Fatah which was a corrupt mafia. Hamas gave them hope with charities and schools.

Now once in power, opposition to Hamas is squelched. In good cases Fatah activists are placed under house arrest, sometimes they are dragged out of hospital beds and executed.

So I challenge you to follow your own advice "to view also the economic and politic dimensions." It is up to the West to protect the people of Gaza just as the West linked human rights to trade with the USSR and the People's Republic of China. To look towards Gazans to fight for post-materialist aims such as human rights is to misjudge their realistic abilities under such desperation.

I agree with your assessment that it is "a war between civilization and people who want to destroy the 'freedom' of the modern world." So where are the allies of Freedom from the West? Why aren't they taking any action against Hamas' regime?

Jan 18, 2009
east/west jive?
You label something eastern because you think it sounds hip, like a a trend... but that is a lot of bullshit when someone is sending a rocket in first blood. You can't hide behind some exotic bullshit.
Eastern philosophy would see all this as cyclical and therefor would see no evolution from Hamas. It is the west which has always been a revolution/evolution mind frame. This mindset of linear thought is the blueprint for "change", not the "Conservative" orient. If I were to think in an Eastern mindset I would laugh at the dialog here. I'm not hailing to be from either mindset, take the cucumber out of your sphincter and talk English.
Jan 18, 2009
Noah Simon said...
seriously get annoyed when people have pretensions when they talk about something basic like self defense. when someone labels you East or West and what not... I call them out. I don't care where the hell school of thought you come from. you shoot a rocket at my family. I'm going to protect my family by any means necessary. Any Zen mother fuckers can kiss my ass.
Jan 18, 2009
I've been thinking a lot about what I should post here. I've tried to articulate my thoughts but unable to express it in a way I thought would be "good" enough. Then, I came across this blog post by Inji Pennu which I echoed my thoughts exactly:

http://mutiny.in/2009/01/11/the-shades-of-gray/
Jan 18, 2009
Noah Simon said...
more jive. it is not proven that Israel supported Hamas and frankly if they did I don't blame them. I have heard that hogwash coming from France and there is mention of it on Wikipedia, but it is unfounded and it is wrong of you to link to a quote of it without claiming the contention of the claim. Bringing the Torah and Quran into this is misleading... Israel is a state that started due to existential issues. You deny life when you blame religion here because it is a completely false claim. In fact the claim of Israel supporting Hamas is based on the contention by the socialists that Israel was attempting to push Palestine out of the socialist movement. total hogwash, but you are using both sides of the argument to further your hate. On the one side you are saying the issue has religious overtones, and yet at the same time you blame Israel for pushing Palestine out of a non religious "modernist" point of view. I happen to not be a socialist and feel there is nothing Modern about Marxist century old thought, but the accusation in the above post that have come out of France have over tones of believing that the Jews are purely religious and yet they are blamed for pushing Palestine out of socialist circles? Why? It makes no sense!

there is no shades of gray for first blood. talking about how Israel does not give Gaza autonomy is insincere. how can you give autonomy to a place that is next door and has a pattern of shooting rockets? Does Hamas rockets hitting Dimona causing a nuclear holocaust on a global level have any shades of gray for you? To dissect and create categories comfortable for a world view, to claim objectivity... but when the gun is pointed to your head I guarantee you won't be so witty. this isn't rocket science. I don't need a PHD to understand what "Death" means. empathy for the plight of the Jews and Palestinians won't help you when the Iranians get a powerful missile into Gaza. you have no understanding that Gaza is not pro life. they want to die. do you want to die?
here is a deep philosophical analysis on the situation:
http://www.metacafe.com/watch/618944/do_you_feel_lucky_punk/

Leave a comment...

 
Got an account with one of these? Login here, or just enter your comment below.
Posterous-login    Connect    twitter